Article Sidebar

Submitted
April 9, 2024
Published
April 10, 2024
Download
Requires Subscription PDF
Statistic
Read Counter : 45 Download : 1

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Main Article Content

Abstract

Halon 1301 is an effective total flooding fire suppression agent which is widely employed in aircraft cargo and propulsion systems for emergency fire scenarios. The production of Halon 1301 was banned by the Montreal Protocol in 1994 due to its environmental impact on ozone depletion and long atmospheric lifetime. Thus, a credible alternative is required for fire safety application on-board aircrafts. This study forms a follow-up to the work published by A. Dinesh et.al and M. Diakostefanis et.al which studied halon-free fire suppression in aircraft cargo bay through CFD and experimental validation respectively. Due to constraints in cost and logistics of testing fire suppression in a gas turbine engine, a computer modelled fire zone of a hypothetical high-bypass turbofan engine was used to simulate and evaluate the fire suppression performance of three Halon-free agents - HFC-125, HFC-227ea and FIC-13I1. Halon 1301 was also simulated to provide baseline comparison to the alternative agents. The capacity to inert was based on the distribution of agent concentrations subjected to a heptane-based fuel fire. Simulations were conducted at ISASLS and 40,000 feet to represent the engine’s operating environment. Overall, it was found that HFC-125 and HFC-227ea satisfactorily suppressed fire at both ambient scenarios. It was found that agent density and suppression concentration significantly influenced the agent’s ability to mix with ambient air and flood the fire zone. Density of the agent combined with higher inertion concentrations also influenced formation of localised recirculation zones which influenced mixture distribution in the fire zone. The simulations enabled identification of individual changes to agent flow characteristics at different operating conditions and demonstrated the performance criteria of Halon 1301 along with the proposed alternative agents for successful fire suppression. Through this study, it was found that all the agents except FIC-13I1 passed the minimum suppression criteria making HFC-125 and HFC-227ea suitable agents for replacement of Halon 1301. The minimum concentration and simulation design in the engine fire zone were validated against the experimental tests conducted by NIST in Boeing 777’s dual-spool high bypass turbofan engine for Halon 1301 and HFC-125. The failure of FIC-13I1 was attributed to the complex design in fire zone and could be overcome by considering a higher factor of safety for this design and injecting higher mass flow rate of the agent into the fire zone. The outcome of this study proposes further work to be carried out through experimental validation of the CFD simulations which will be key to progress the technology to higher TRL and meet aviation certification requirements. Further work may also explore blended agent configurations to tailor the agent characteristics to meet suppression requirements for maintaining safety and reliability of the system.

Keywords

Gas Turbine, Extinguish, Fire Zone, Inert, Suppress, HFC-125

Article Details

How to Cite
Dinesh, A., Diakostefanis, M., & Sampath, S. (2024). Assessment of Halon-Free Agents for Fire Safety Application in Aircraft Propulsion System. Journal of Aerospace Sciences and Technologies, 76(1), 19–33. https://doi.org/10.61653/joast.v76i1.2024.939
Download Citation
Endnote/Zotero/Mendeley (RIS)
BibTeX

References

  1. Clean Sky 2, "Aviation Environment: Clean Sky 2", Horizon 2020: EU Funding for Research and Innovation, 2016. [Online] Available: http://www.cleansky.eu/content/home-page/aviation-environment. [Accessed: 29-Apr-2022].
  2. Management of Environmental Protection in Defence, "Control of Ozone Depleting Substances Used in Fire Protection in the EU", Fire Ind. Assoc., Vol. FIA Enviro, No.03, pp.1-2.
  3. P. Huerta, M., "FAA Halon ARC Final Report: Findings and Recommendations", US.
  4. "Halon: Update of Part-26 to Comply with ICAO Standards - Notice of Proposed Amendment 2014-26".
  5. Solomon, S., Ivy, D.J., Kinnison, D., Mills, M.J., R. R. N. III. and Schmidt, A., "Emergence of Healing in the Antarctic Ozone Layer, Science @ science.sciencemag.org", Science Magazine, Science AAAS, June 2016.
  6. Borghhetti, L., Chaer, D., Ferguson, D., Finck, B., Kallergis, K., Lyon, E.A., Deugra, K. and Stewart, H., "Options for Aircraft Engine Fire Protection", 2000.
  7. U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration, "Fire Protection Systems", Aviat. Maint. Tech. Handb.. - Airframe, pp.1-22, 2012.
  8. L. et al., Ingerson, D Speitel., "Status of Research and Testing to Replace Halon Extinguishing Agents in Civil Aviation", FAA William J Hughes Tech. Cent., p.7.
  9. Unknown Author, "Federal Aviation Administration, 2015 Fire Safety Highlights", Fire Saf. Highlights, pp.12-15, 2015.
  10. Hariram, D., Philipp, S. and Dummeyer, P., "Fire Protection: Engines and Auxiliary Power Units", Aero Mag. Boeing, No.QTR_04.10, 2010.
  11. "National Fire Protection Agency 12A, Standard on Halon 1301 Fire Extinguishing Systems", 2015.
  12. C. Grant, C., "Society of Fire Protection Engineering: Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering", in Halon Design Calculations, 5th Edition, M. Hurley, Editor, Springer, 2016, pp.1450-1482.
  13. Speitel, L.C., "Options to the Use of Halons for Aircraft Fire Suppression Systems - 2012 Update, Federal Aviation Administration", Atlantic City, 2012.
  14. Dinesh, A., Benson, C.M., Holborn, P.G., Sampath, S. and Xiong, Y., "Performance Evaluation of Nitrogen for Fire Safety Application in Aircraft, Reliability Engineering and System Safety", 202, October 2020, Article No.107044.
  15. Xiong, Y., Diakostefanis, M., Sampath, S. and Dinesh, A., "Numerical Assessment for Aircraft Cargo Compartment Fire Suppression System Safety", Journal of Fire Sciences, 39 (3), 2021, pp.240-261.
  16. Diakostefanis, M., Sampath, S., Dinesh, A., Beuermann, R. and Malkogianni, A., "Nitrogen as an Environmentally Friendly Suppression Agent for Aircraft Cargo Fire Safety", Journal of Fire Sciences, 39 (5), 2021, pp.400-424.
  17. Widely, M., et al., "HFCs, the Montreal Protocol and the UNFCCC : Eliminating 1 of the 6 Kyoto Gases", Environmental Investigation Agency, September, 2012, pp.2-5.
  18. Ingerson, D., "Simulating the Distribution of Halon 1301 in an Aircraft Engine Nacelle with HFC-125", DOT/FAA/AR-TN99/64.
  19. Bennett, R., "Replacing Halon in Fire Protection Systems : A Progress Report", Boeing Aero Mag. Q., Vol.QTR_04, No.04.
  20. Bein, D. P., "A Review of the History of Fire Suppression on US DOD Aircraft", Lakehurst, 2006.
  21. Box, P.O. and Horrocks, D. M., "The Numerical Simulation and Experimental Validation of Ventilation Flow and Fire Events in a Trent Nacelle Fire Zone", Rolls Royce ICAS 2000 Congr., No.681, pp.1-10, 2000.
  22. Kim, S.K., Lestina, T.J., Giesecke, H.D. and Sheinson, R.S., "Development of Computer Models for the Discharge of Halon Alternatives", Halon Options Tech. Work. Conf. (HOTWC)-1994, pp.425-430, 1994.
  23. Daly, M., IHS Jane’s Aero-Engines, 2014th-201st Edition, Jane’s and IHS Markit.
  24. "Delavan Spray Technologies - Aerospace Turbine Fuel Nozzles", Turbine Fuel Technologies, 2016. [Online] Available: http://www.delavan.co.uk/. [Accessed: 06-May-2016].
  25. Kaufmann, K.J., Company, T.B., Wozniak, G., Mitchell, M.D. and Aerospace, W.K., "Results of Halon 1301 and HFC-125 Concentration Tests on a Large Commercial Aircraft Engine Installation", National Institute of Standards and Technology, pp.211-222, 1995.
  26. Hewson, J.C., Park, P.T., Hill, P. and Rd, R., "Predicting Fire Suppression in a Simulated Engine Nacelle 1 Introduction 2 Overall Geometry", pp. 1-15.
  27. DiNenno, W., P, J. and Forssell, E., "Clean Agent Total Flooding Fire Extinguishing Systems", Society of Fire Protection Engineering: Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering, 5th Edition, Springer, 2016, pp.1483-1530.
  28. Sheinson, R, et al., "Halon 1301 Replacement Total Flooding Fire Testing Intermediate Scale", 1994.
  29. C. Brockway, J., "Recent Findings on Thermal Decomposition Products of Clean Extinguishing Agents", 2001.
  30. Park, B., "NFPA 12A Standard on Halon 1301 Fire Extinguishing Systems 2004 Edition", Natl. Fire Prot. Agency, pp.1-58, 2004.